Aunty Mary’s

Reviews

• Ms. L.

  star star star star star_border 7 June 2026

  Very good fish & chips, charming decor & atmosphere. The rushing waitress apologized for their expensive soft drinks - which are something like $1.35 - and we didn't have the heart to tell her that isn't expensive at all!
  
  The fish is heavy on the batter, but if you want that sinful fish & chips platter in a place with no pretensions, this place is perfect. Feels like a 1950s diner without the front counter or, thankfully, the racism. At least as far as I saw.

• Abigail B.

  star star star star star 2 June 2026

  It's a Scarborough staple. You have to try their fish and chips, you'll never be disappointed. I wish I took a photo but I couldn't fight the temptation and dug in before I could.

• Maggie J.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 29 May 2026

  I had heard this was a good place for fish and chips and was in the area so thought I'd try it. Well first of all when I walked in the entrance i could smell what seemed like a backed up toilet. Not a good first impression. Then I saw the sign that they take cash only. Who doesn't take some form of plastic these days? Instead of listening to my instincts i went to get cash and returned. I ordered the fish and chips, not sure if I got halibut or haddock because the server didn't ask which I wanted and there was no printed menu just a menu over the counter area.
  
  I must say the place looks like a real dive, very run down and in need of some renovations. The food came very quickly and the server seemed quite efficient. The fries were supermarket frozen fries, and they weren't very appealing. The fish batter was just dripping with grease as was the one onion ring on top of the fries. I was only given one napkin and I used that to try to soak up the grease. I had a vision of their deep fryer and I though I bet the oil never gets changed. Anyways I got an upset stomach within about an hour of eating there.
  
  Weirdly enough I got my bill and it just said fish and chips and Pepsi but no detailed price nor a total. So my bill when I went to the cash register to pay was $12 and change.
  
  Needless to say I won't be back. I'm really surprised at some of the reviews where people said 'best fish and chips in the city'. The fish itself wasn't even nice and flaky the way it's supposed to be so I suspect it's was frozen as well.

• Micheal D.

  star star star star star 15 May 2026

  This is the best restaurant in Scarborough!!!! The owners are extremity polite and full of respect. I've been coming here since I was a little kid and never have I been disappointed yet by their service and food!!!! The fish and chips are amazing especially with the tar tar sauce. They have many options ranging from veggie, chicken, pork, beef. My favourite food will always be the banquet burger it's always made fresh and flamed grilled unlike McDonald's and Burger King which they keep in hot holding units that ruins quality and taste!!! Believe me when I say this customer service at other fast food places or restaurants has gone down completely but Aunty Mary's will always and continue to be the best in customer service!! Thank you for reading this review.

• Felix A.

  star star star star star_border 12 May 2026

  Best fish and chips and onion rings. Breakfast so cheap and good. Service always  good and the owners are very friendly.